A Seasonal Message from Professor Patricia Riddell & Ian McDermott
As Christmas approaches, we anticipate this with differing amounts of trepidation and excitement. There appears to be considerable pressure to enjoy the day and to make sure everyone is happy – which raises the question “Do we know what makes us happy?”
The simple answer to this is that activity in the dopamine reward centers makes us feel happy – problem solved. Receiving presents that we really wanted does that – doesn’t it? And the more expensive the present, the greater the appreciation? All we need to do is to make sure that we drop enough hints and we can ensure ourselves a happy Christmas.
But does this match our experience? If you think back to Christmases past, which do you remember, and what is it about them that makes them memorable?
Here’s one of Patricia’s experiences. “One of the things that I remember most about Christmases with my family was that my parents would write a skit for us and then we would act this out (very badly) in teams. Props and costumes would be provided, but it was up to each team how they used these. Much creativity would go into dividing up parts (always with too few people to play them all). I vividly remember making up faces so that each half of my face represented a different character and then having to remember which way to be facing for which lines. Our team won the skit competition that year as a result of this simple piece of ingenuity! I still smile when I recall this particularly happy memory, but I have no idea what Christmas gifts I received that year.“
What makes this happen turns out to be a lot more complicated than we might imagine, and even throws up some research findings that at first are counterintuitive. Indeed, it suggests that some of our intuitions about what might make us happy are wrong!
A bit of knowledge about the way that our brains work might help us to make Christmas happier. Here, we have put together some top tips to help:
- When we receive things we thought we really wanted, we are happy for less time than we anticipate (Wilson & Gilbert, 2008; Kurtz, 2016). This has been termed affective forecasting, and studies have shown that we anticipate the effects of both intensely negative and intensely positive events will last for longer than they do. The pleasure and novelty of a much-anticipated event soon wears off.
Action: Remember to enjoy the anticipation of the holidays to the fullest!
- Surprise, uncertainty and curiosity prolong our happiness. (Wilson, Centerbar, Kermer & Gilbert, 2005). Remember when Christmas was magical because we didn’t know whether Santa would bring the gifts we wanted, and not knowing how he came down the chimney (or otherwise managed to get into our house)? And – we really didn’t want to know the answer. Research suggests that when we make sense of events, we lose the emotional intensity – so just enjoy the magic of the holidays and don’t try to explain why it works.
Action: Consider how you can make the holiday season more magical.
- Sometimes, on the run up to the holidays, we might find ourselves wishing the holidays could be cancelled. But what would it really be like if there were no holidays? Research by Koo, Algoe, Wilson & Gilbert (2008) has demonstrated that people are happier after they have reflected on the absence of an event than when imagining the same event.
Action: If you find yourself wishing that the holidays could be cancelled – imagine this in full, technicolor detail to remind yourself of all the reasons why this would be a bad idea.
- For us our, favorite holiday memories when we look back, involve acting out family skits, playing games and cooking for the whole family as a family (Patricia), taking three generations, their partners and children to Key West for Christmas or being on massive extended meditation retreats with strangers, mince pies and roaring log fires). All of these involve some level of personal challenge, which fits with the research that shows we are happiest when we are challenged – not when we are bored (Waterman, 1993).
Action: Find ways to add personal challenge to your holiday plans for both yourself and your loved ones.
- Patricia: “I remember one Christmas when I couldn’t be with family and spent part of the day helping to feed people who had nowhere to go and nothing to eat at Christmas. I remember this as one of the happiest Christmases I have had.” The research suggests being with others makes us happy (Diener & Seligman, 2002) – especially when we are helping others.
Action: Use some time over this holiday season to do actively something for others.
- When we remember happy events, is it the intensity of the happiness we experience or the frequency of happiness that causes the memory to be remembered positively? Would we be better doing something really special at one point on Christmas day or are lots of little pleasures more effective in creating a happy memory of the day? Studies have compared how happy participants feel based on the intensity versus the frequency of happy moments in a day. What these have shown is that it is the frequency of our positive experiences which is a better predictor of our happiness than the intensity of the experience (Thomas & Diener, 2002).
Action: Think about how you can have lots of little pleasures throughout your holiday to create a really happy memory.
- Can you recall a fantastic holiday or even a great Christmas day from the past? What do you remember specifically from that day that made it so special? Research suggests that we remember events as having been really positive experiences if the last thing that happened was positive (Fredrickson & Kahneman, 1993).
Action: Purposefully plan your holiday get-together so that there is a highlight at the end of the day.
- We are happier when we give than when we receive (Dunn, Aknin & Norton, 2008). In this study, people were given either $5 or $20 and given instructions to either spend this on themselves (paying a bill or buying a gift) or on others (gift for others or charity donation). Those who were randomly assigned to spend money on others were happier after the event than those who spent money on themselves. Ian: “When I learned that ensuring people either get their own home or don’t lose their home is one of the most important things we can do to affect their overall life chances, I realized I could make a difference. That’s why I started regularly donating to charities which focus specifically on what’s called ‘housing first’.”
Action: Think less about the gifts we might get, and focus more on what, how, when and to whom we might give.
Wishing you all a very Happy Holiday season!
Become a Member for Your Expertly Curated Advice
Joining the Family Wealth Library means access to the information the legacy builders need to navigate family dynamics and protect our wealth. We can keep what is ours by managing familial challenges and building trust and transparency.